Author’s Note
Who Put the Crabs in the Barrel? emerged from a reflection shared by a colleague in Chicago that returned me to an expression I had encountered repeatedly during childhood. Even then, I found myself puzzled by the metaphor, particularly its tendency to direct attention toward the behaviour of the crabs while leaving the circumstances of their confinement largely unexamined. Years later, informed by my studies in history, sociology, and consciousness and human potential, I find that the question has acquired considerably greater significance.
My intention is not to dismiss the reality of jealousy, competition, or the deliberate obstruction of another person’s advancement. Such behaviours sadly exist, and individuals remain responsible for their conduct. Rather, I am interested in the limitations of explanations that attribute social difficulties primarily to individual character while neglecting the historical, economic, and institutional arrangements within which those difficulties emerge. This concern is particularly consequential when applied to communities whose experiences have been shaped by exclusion and unequal access to opportunity.
Ultimately, this essay extends an enquiry that has become increasingly central to my work: how the constructs through which we organise human life influence the outcomes we subsequently interpret as evidence of human nature. If we can recognise that many of the conditions shaping our collective experience are human-derived rather than inevitable, we may also begin to recognise our capacity and responsibility to reconsider them. The objective is not simply to identify who constructed the barrel, but to explore what might become possible when we develop the awareness and willingness to create something different.
—Baruti KMT-Sisouvong, PhD
I recently came across a Facebook post from a colleague in Chicago that discussed a perhaps well-known phenomenon within some sectors of society—Crabs in a Barrel.
I recall hearing of this term during my childhood from adults as it was often stated as a sad reality within their friend groups. It often sounded something akin to: “If it were not for the Crabs in a barrel mindset, so-and-so would be more successful.” The thinking being that were the person under discussion to have been successful in their venture, they would then be in a position to assist others in doing likewise. There is merit to this thinking. We see it among some groups where when one amongst the crew becomes successful, they subsequently tap their friends who have the necessary skillset and growth mindset to meaningfully contribute to the enterprise. Even as a kid hearing the adults discuss it, I was always puzzled. Because I never saw crabs naturally in a barrel. I say naturally because the times I did see them in a container was either within a supermarket, seafood restaurant, or on one of the various cooking shows I would watch as they are being prepared to become part of a meal. So, again, I was puzzled. That was until I became a young adult and began navigating the social world.
All these years later, I still hold that there is an interesting peculiarity in the expression crabs in a barrel. When invoked to explain human behaviour, the metaphor generally directs our attention toward the crabs, particularly their apparent tendency to prevent one another from escaping the barrel. As a result, the animals become symbols of jealousy, competition, resentment, and the base and destructive impulses that supposedly emerge when individuals encounter the possibility of another’s advancement. Within this interpretation, the central problem resides in the behaviour of the crabs themselves, whose apparent unwillingness to permit another to rise becomes evidence of some inherent deficiency in their collective disposition.
Yet there is a question embedded within the metaphor that receives comparatively little attention. As mentioned above, crabs do not ordinarily inhabit barrels. They exist within ecological environments whose conditions, resources, and relationships differ considerably from those of a confined container. The barrel then represents an imposed arrangement, one that restricts movement, concentrates individuals within a limited space, and establishes conditions that would not necessarily characterise their ordinary environment. Whatever behaviour emerges under those circumstances cannot be understood adequately without considering the conditions in which it occurs because context matters.
This distinction came to mind as I encountered and continued to ruminate on the reflection. Perhaps as a result of my training in Sociology at both the undergrad and graduate level, my mind immediately thought rather than focusing upon the crabs’ apparent tendency to pull one another down, what about drawing attention toward the barrel itself. Who placed the crabs within it? Why do they remain there? And why are we so inclined to blame the animals while overlooking the conditions under which their behaviour is being observed? Then I turned my attention to the real life human behaviours the metaphor seeks to explain. And the more I reflected, the more I found the questions compelling, not because they eliminate the possibility of individual responsibility, but because they expose a limitation in the way we frequently interpret human conduct. We often begin our explanations with the behaviour that is most immediately visible, treating it as evidence of the character, intentions, or capacities of the individuals involved. However, less frequently do we examine the social constructs and arrangements, economic pressures, institutional expectations, and historical circumstances that may contribute to producing the very behaviours we seek to explain and in some cases pathologise. For me, the metaphor therefore invites a reconsideration of a familiar assumption: that the conduct of individuals can be adequately understood independently of the environments in which they act.
My interest in this question is not new. As someone whose intellectual development has been shaped by history, sociology, consciousness studies, and the examination of human-derived social systems, I have long been interested in the relationship between individuals and the structures through which their lives unfold. Because human beings do not simply inhabit a world of independently existing social arrangements. We participate in constructing, maintaining, interpreting, and sometimes even transforming the institutions, classifications, expectations, and systems of authority that organise our collective experience. These arrangements subsequently influence the opportunities available to us, the constraints we encounter, and the ways we understand both ourselves and one another.
There is a reciprocal relationship at work. Human beings create social structures, and those structures, once established, influence the behaviour of the human beings who operate within them. Over time, arrangements that originated through particular historical decisions may come to appear natural, inevitable, or beyond meaningful reconsideration. Their effects become so familiar due to our being born into them mid-sentence, that we begin to mistake the outcomes they produce for characteristics inherent in the people experiencing them. The barrel, in other words, gradually disappears from our field of attention, even as its influence remains.
The Problem of Misplaced Attribution
Social psychology provides a useful point of departure for understanding this tendency. Researchers have examined how people explain behaviour by attributing it either to characteristics of the individual or to circumstances surrounding the individual. One influential concept is described as the fundamental attribution error. Coined by Stanford Professor of Humanities and Sciences Lee David Ross in 1977, the term concerns the tendency to overemphasise personal dispositions while underestimating situational influences when interpreting the conduct of others.
Although, admittedly, the strength and generality of this tendency vary across circumstances and cultural contexts, the underlying distinction remains valuable. When we observe someone behaving competitively, defensively, or aggressively, we may interpret that conduct as evidence of an enduring personality characteristic. We may even conclude that the individual is being selfish, jealous, insecure, or categorically unwilling to cooperate. Yet such conclusions can overlook the possibility that the person is responding to conditions in which resources are scarce, opportunities are constrained, or the consequences of failing to protect one’s immediate interests are unusually severe.
Consider two individuals employed within the same organisation who are expected to collaborate in advancing a shared mission. Under favourable circumstances, their relationship may be characterised by cooperation, the exchange of information, and mutual support. Each understands that the success of the other contributes to the success of the larger enterprise, and the organisational arrangements provide sufficient stability for collaboration to flourish. Now imagine that the organisation begins experiencing financial difficulties. Resources become increasingly limited, previously available support diminishes, and each individual is expected to demonstrate that their particular area of responsibility can remain viable. The organisation continues to emphasise collaboration, but its financial arrangements increasingly reward individual performance while providing little assurance that collective success will translate into sufficient support for everyone involved.
Under such conditions, the relationship between our two parties may begin to change. Information that was once shared freely may be guarded more carefully. Opportunities that previously appeared mutually beneficial may come to be understood as competitive. The success of one individual may increasingly be interpreted as a potential loss for another, particularly when both depend upon access to the same limited resources. In this instance, an outside observer encountering the resulting tension might conclude that the individuals have become territorial, uncooperative, or excessively concerned with their own advancement. Such an interpretation would not necessarily be false, but it would remain incomplete if it failed to consider the conditions under which their relationship had changed.
The individuals may still bear responsibility for how they treat one another. They may retain opportunities to communicate more effectively, exercise restraint, and pursue arrangements that reduce unnecessary competition. Nevertheless, understanding their conduct requires more than identifying the attitudes displayed within the immediate interaction. It also requires examining whether the larger system has created incentives that make cooperation increasingly difficult to sustain. Here, for me, is where the barrel becomes especially relevant. The same individuals who might collaborate under one set of conditions may behave quite differently under another. Their conduct cannot be understood solely through presumed deficiencies of character, particularly when the environment has altered the relationship between their individual interests and their collective responsibilities.
When the Metaphor Becomes a Social Diagnosis
The expression crabs in a barrel has acquired particular significance within discussions of Black communities, where it has often been invoked to describe perceived patterns of intragroup competition, resentment, and resistance to the advancement of others. In some applications, the metaphor suggests that individuals who achieve a measure of success encounter opposition from members of their own community who are unwilling to see them rise beyond circumstances they themselves continue to experience. To be clear, there are undoubtedly situations in which jealousy, rivalry, or the deliberate obstruction of another person’s advancement contribute to interpersonal conflict. I have experienced such in more thana few instances ove the course of my life and professional career. Despite such, the behaviour is not confined to any particular ethnic or cultural population, nor should its existence be dismissed simply because broader structural explanations are available. Human beings possess the capacity for generosity and cooperation, but they also possess the capacity for resentment, competition, and conduct that undermines the well-being of others. Stated plainly, humans can be petty af. The difficulty, however, arises when the metaphor is employed as a general explanation of the behaviour of an entire community, particularly one whose historical circumstances have been shaped by exclusion, coercion, and unequal access to resources.
Within the United States, the development of African American social and economic life cannot be understood independently of slavery, segregation, discriminatory housing arrangements, unequal educational opportunities, restrictions upon economic participation, and the continuing consequences of institutions that distributed resources and opportunities along socially constructed racial lines. These circumstances did not eliminate individual agency, nor did they produce a uniform pattern of behaviour among those who experienced them. Nevertheless, they established conditions under which the pursuit of advancement frequently occurred within environments characterised by externally imposed constraints i.e. the barrel.
When competition emerges within such environments, it becomes necessary to distinguish between behaviour that reflects individual choices and behaviour influenced by the structure of the opportunities available. If access to employment, housing, education, professional advancement, or institutional recognition is restricted, individuals may encounter circumstances in which the success of one person appears to reduce the opportunities available to another. The resulting tensions may then be interpreted as evidence of a collective inability to cooperate, even when the conditions producing those tensions have received comparatively little attention. The danger therefore is not merely that the explanation becomes incomplete. It is that the people experiencing the constraints may become identified as the principal source of the difficulties those constraints help produce.
This pattern has appeared repeatedly within the history of social thought. Populations subjected to unequal conditions have often been evaluated through standards that treat the consequences of those conditions as evidence of inherent deficiencies. Economic insecurity becomes interpreted as a failure of discipline, restricted educational opportunities become evidence of limited intellectual capacity, and the consequences of exclusion become explanations for why exclusion should continue.
The reasoning is circular, but its circularity can become difficult to recognise when the conditions responsible for producing particular outcomes remain outside the observer’s field of attention.
I explored a related concern in my earlier essay, The Pathology of the Gaze, where I considered the consequences of directing scrutiny toward marginalised populations while insufficiently examining the systems through which their marginalisation has been produced and sustained. The present metaphor extends that enquiry by inviting us to consider how the behaviour of people operating within constrained environments may become the principal object of criticism while the arrangements shaping those environments remain comparatively unexamined.
The question therefore is not whether individuals should be held accountable for their conduct. Rather, it is whether accountability can be meaningful when our explanations systematically overlook the circumstances that influence the choices available to them.
The Architecture of Competition
The implications of this question extend well beyond racial and cultural relationships. They are equally relevant to educational institutions, professional organisations, religious communities, businesses, and other social arrangements whose participants are expected to pursue shared objectives. Because institutions frequently describe themselves through the language of common purpose. Their missions emphasise service, education, advancement, innovation, or the improvement of human well-being. Yet the arrangements through which those missions are pursued do not always distribute resources, responsibilities, and authority in ways that support the collaborative relationships necessary for their achievement.
Consider an organisation composed of several local operations, each responsible for serving a particular community while contributing resources to a larger administrative structure. The organisation may benefit collectively whenever any location succeeds in advancing its mission. Yet the local operations may depend upon revenue generated within their immediate areas to meet their own financial obligations. Now, under stable conditions, the tension between local sustainability and collective purpose may remain manageable. Shared resources, coordinated planning, and institutional support can help ensure that the success of one location contributes to the strength of the others. However, when the larger organisation experiences financial strain, the relationship may become more complicated. Local operations may be expected to assume greater responsibility for their own sustainability while continuing to contribute resources to the central structure. Support that previously helped maintain cooperation may diminish, even as the need for local revenue becomes more urgent.
Under these circumstances, two locations pursuing the same mission may begin to experience one another as competitors. An opportunity secured by one may be perceived as an opportunity lost by the other, even when the larger organisation benefits from either outcome. In such a case, the resulting tension may be interpreted as a failure of communication or a lack of goodwill between the individuals involved. And, yes, those factors may indeed contribute to the difficulty. Yet the more consequential question concerns whether the organisation’s arrangements have created conditions in which participants are encouraged to pursue collective objectives while simultaneously being required to compete for the resources necessary to remain viable.
In organisational economics, this resembles a problem of misaligned incentives. The outcomes that benefit the larger system do not necessarily produce corresponding benefits for each participant within it. Consequently, individuals may behave in ways that protect their immediate responsibilities while inadvertently undermining the cooperation upon which the larger mission depends. In my experience, the irony is that the participants may share precisely the same underlying commitments. Their disagreements need not arise from competing philosophies, incompatible values, or personal animosity. They may instead emerge because the institutional environment has made the practical requirements of their respective responsibilities increasingly difficult to reconcile. Such a system can therefore generate conflict among people who would otherwise have considerable reason to collaborate. As a result, this possibility should give us reason to examine institutional design with greater care. Because, when organisations repeatedly experience competition, mistrust, or territorial behaviour among individuals pursuing shared objectives, it may be insufficient to respond exclusively through appeals for improved attitudes or greater cooperation. Such appeals can be valuable, but they cannot necessarily overcome arrangements that consistently reward the very behaviours the organisation allegedly seeks to discourage. For if the architecture of the system makes cooperation costly and competition necessary for survival, the problem cannot be resolved adequately by asking participants to behave as though those conditions do not exist.
The Human-Derived World and the Consequences of Our Constructs
These considerations connect directly to the framework I have developed through the Seven Layers of Manifestation. Within that framework, the relationship between the Phenomenal World, Human Consciousness, the Human-Derived World, Constructs, and Outcomes provides a way of examining how human beings participate in creating the circumstances through which their individual and collective experiences unfold.
The Phenomenal World exists as a result of the expression of Universal and Natural Laws, whose functioning does not depend upon human preference or institutional agreement. Human Consciousness, however, participates in interpreting experience and developing the arrangements through which individuals and communities organise their activities. Through the Human-Derived World, we establish institutions, economic systems, educational arrangements, professional expectations, and other structures intended to facilitate particular purposes. To be crystal clear, these arrangements are not identical to the natural laws within which they operate. They are instead human creations, shaped by assumptions, priorities, historical circumstances, and decisions that may subsequently become embedded within the functioning of institutions.
Over time, such arrangements can acquire an appearance of permanence. Rules that originated as responses to particular circumstances may continue operating long after those circumstances have changed. Economic arrangements that once supported institutional stability may become increasingly difficult to sustain. Classifications that were initially introduced for administrative convenience may begin influencing how individuals understand themselves and one another. Seen in this light, the constructs through which human beings organise their collective activities therefore possess consequences that extend well beyond their original intentions.
Within the Seven Layers of Manifestation, Outcomes invite consideration not merely of what has occurred, but of the relationships among the conditions, constructs, and activities through which particular results have emerged. And when an institution produces recurring patterns of competition, exclusion, or mistrust, those outcomes may reveal something about the arrangements through which the institution itself operates.
This does not mean that every outcome can be traced to a single institutional decision, nor does it imply that individuals lack the capacity to act independently of their circumstances. Human behaviour is shaped by multiple interacting influences, including personal history, psychological dispositions, cultural expectations, social relationships, and the conditions of the surrounding environment. Nevertheless, the SLM framework encourages us to distinguish between the arrangements human beings have constructed and the outcomes those arrangements help produce. It also invites us to recognise that arrangements created through human activity may be reconsidered through human activity. The barrel, after all, is not a Natural Law.
It is instead a constructed environment whose dimensions, constraints, and purposes reflect decisions made outside the ordinary circumstances of the animals confined within it. If those conditions contribute to the behaviour being observed, then examining the behaviour without examining the container provides only a partial understanding of the situation itself.
The same principle applies to human institutions, although the complexity of human consciousness, agency, and social organisation requires a considerably more sophisticated analysis than the metaphor itself can provide. For me, the value of the metaphor lies not in reducing human beings to animals confined within a container, but in reminding us that the environments through which behaviour emerges deserve examination alongside the behaviour itself.
The Difference Between Explanation and Excuse
At this point, I believe an important distinction becomes necessary. To examine the structural conditions influencing behaviour is not to suggest that individuals bear no responsibility for their actions. Nor does identifying an institutional contribution to conflict establish that every participant has acted reasonably or that all conduct should be understood as an unavoidable consequence of circumstance.
Human beings possess capacities for reflection, deliberation, cooperation, and intentional refinement. We can recognise circumstances that encourage particular responses and nevertheless choose to act differently. We can examine our assumptions, reconsider our relationships, and develop approaches that reduce unnecessary harm even when the larger conditions remain difficult. Indeed, I wholeheartedly believe the capacity to recognise the influence of circumstances may strengthen rather than diminish personal responsibility. When individuals understand how their built environment shapes their thoughts, perceptions, and incentives, they may become better equipped to distinguish between responses that merely reproduce existing patterns and responses that contribute to changing them. As a result, a person who recognises that institutional arrangements encourage competition may become more deliberate about maintaining collaborative relationships. A leader who understands how resource constraints influence behaviour may reconsider whether established expectations remain appropriate. A community that recognises the historical conditions contributing to particular difficulties may develop strategies that address both individual conduct and the arrangements within which that conduct occurs. Seen from this perspective, explanation and excuse are therefore not synonymous.
An explanation seeks to understand the conditions contributing to an outcome. An excuse, on the other hand, attempts to remove or diminish responsibility for conduct that may nevertheless warrant examination. The former can contribute to more effective accountability precisely because it provides a fuller understanding of the circumstances in which decisions are made.
This distinction is especially important when discussing communities whose members have experienced historical marginalisation. Structural analysis should not become another way of denying individuals the capacity to shape their own lives. To suggest that people are entirely determined by oppressive circumstances would be to replace one reductive account of human behaviour with another. For me, the more useful position recognises that human agency operates within conditions that may expand or constrain the possibilities available for its expression. Individuals can exercise meaningful choice while simultaneously encountering circumstances that influence the costs, consequences, and practical feasibility of those choices. Additionally, a person may possess the capacity to cooperate while operating within a system that makes cooperation economically disadvantageous. Another may value collective advancement while encountering arrangements that reward individual competition. Recognising these tensions does not absolve either person of responsibility, but it helps explain why appeals to shared values may prove insufficient when the structures governing their interactions remain unchanged.
I believe the challenge, dare I say opportunity, is therefore to cultivate individual capacities while also examining whether our collective arrangements support the expression of those capacities.
Beyond the Barrel
If the conditions of the barrel contribute to the behaviour observed within it, then meaningful change may require more than encouraging the crabs to behave differently. It may require reconsidering the arrangement that has placed them in such close confinement and established the conditions under which their movements become mutually constraining.
As related to human communities and institutions, this means recognising that appeals to cooperation, unity, and mutual support are most effective when accompanied by arrangements developed upstream that make those commitments practically sustainable.
An organisation that values collaboration must therefore consider whether its distribution of resources supports collaborative activity. A community that seeks collective advancement must examine whether its institutions provide meaningful opportunities for participation and development. Leaders who expect individuals to pursue shared objectives must consider whether the responsibilities assigned to those individuals are accompanied by sufficient authority, resources, and support to make cooperation viable.
These questions do not imply that every conflict can be eliminated through better institutional design. Human beings will continue to experience differences in perspective, competing priorities, and disagreements concerning the appropriate use of resources. Such differences are not inherently destructive and may contribute to learning and refinement when approached constructively. Nevertheless, we should distinguish between disagreements arising from genuine differences in judgement and conflicts intensified by arrangements that unnecessarily place individuals in competition with one another. The former may require dialogue, compromise, and the cultivation of mutual understanding. The latter may also require changes to the structures through which relationships are organised.
This distinction is consistent with the developmental orientation underlying my Model for Perpetual Growth and Progress born of my doctoral dissertation research and is extensively discussed in the book manuscript for Elegant Transitions. The movement from Knower to Seeker, Tool Development, Intentional Refinement, Sacred Service, and Mastery Through Practice reflects an understanding of development as an ongoing process through which knowledge and experience can inform increasingly conscious action.
When applied to institutional life, such development invites individuals and organisations to examine not merely whether established practices are being followed, but whether those practices continue to support the purposes for which they were created. Assessment and reflection therefore become especially important when familiar arrangements produce outcomes that differ from their stated intentions. Intentional refinement then requires more than identifying deficiencies in the behaviour of participants. It involves reconsidering the assumptions, incentives, and structures that influence how participants understand and pursue their responsibilities.
Sacred Service, within this context, concerns the orientation through which knowledge and capacity are directed toward meaningful contribution. If our institutional arrangements consistently undermine the ability of individuals to cooperate in advancing a shared purpose, then reconsidering those arrangements may itself become an expression of service.
The objective is not to create environments in which every individual receives identical outcomes or encounters no meaningful constraints. Rather, it is to cultivate conditions in which the pursuit of individual development need not unnecessarily diminish the possibilities available to others.
Such an orientation requires us to move beyond the assumption that another person’s advancement must represent our own loss. It also requires recognising that cooperation is not sustained through goodwill alone. It depends upon relationships, expectations, and arrangements that allow individuals to pursue meaningful objectives without being repeatedly placed in circumstances where their survival appears contingent upon another’s failure. The challenge is therefore both personal and structural. We must cultivate the capacities necessary for responsible action while also reconsidering the conditions through which those capacities are expressed.
Changing the Object of Our Attention
As I return to the reflection that prompted this enquiry, I find myself considering how frequently we direct our attention toward the most visible participants in a difficult situation while overlooking the arrangements that have helped produce it. In such instances, we observe competition and ask why people cannot cooperate. We observe economic insecurity and ask why individuals have not made better decisions. We observe conflict within institutions and ask why participants have become so territorial. And we observe communities struggling with the consequences of historical exclusion and ask why their members have not simply overcome the difficulties before them.
These questions may contain legitimate concerns, but they can become grossly misleading when they presume that the behaviour under examination can be understood independently of the conditions within which it occurs. Because there is a difference between asking why people behave as they do and asking what circumstances make particular behaviours more likely. The first question directs attention toward individual conduct, while the second expands the enquiry to include the relationships, constraints, and incentives shaping the possibilities available for action. Neither question is sufficient by itself.
A comprehensive understanding of human behaviour requires attention to both, recognising that individuals participate in creating social arrangements while simultaneously being influenced by the arrangements they inherit.
This is particularly important because the structures governing our collective lives are often treated as though they exist independently of human choice. Institutional policies, economic arrangements, and social classifications can become so familiar that their origins disappear from view. We encounter their consequences as ordinary features of life rather than as outcomes of decisions that might have been made differently. Yet the recognition that an arrangement is human-derived introduces the possibility of reconsidering it.
If we have participated in constructing systems that produce unnecessary competition, we may also possess the capacity to develop arrangements that encourage cooperation. If our institutions distribute responsibilities and resources in ways that undermine their stated missions, we may examine whether those arrangements remain appropriate. And if our interpretations of human behaviour have relied too heavily upon presumed deficiencies of character, we may cultivate a more comprehensive understanding of the circumstances influencing the conduct we observe.
None of this guarantees that meaningful change will be easy. Institutional arrangements often become intertwined with established interests, professional identities, financial obligations, and assumptions about authority. Their modification may require difficult conversations, the reconsideration of longstanding practices, and a willingness to acknowledge that arrangements once regarded as appropriate may no longer serve their intended purposes.
Nevertheless, the difficulty of changing a system should not be confused with evidence that the system cannot be changed. Because the barrel may be familiar, but familiarity does not establish inevitability.
Who Put the Crabs in the Barrel?
The question that gives this essay its title is therefore more than a rhetorical challenge. It is an invitation to reconsider where we direct our attention when attempting to understand the difficulties that emerge within human communities and institutions.
Sometimes the answer will involve identifiable decisions made by particular individuals or organisations. At other times, the conditions under examination may have developed gradually through the interaction of historical circumstances, economic arrangements, cultural expectations, and institutional practices whose origins are no longer immediately apparent.
In either case, the question encourages us to examine the environment rather than assuming that the behaviour observed within it provides a complete explanation of the problem.
There is also a further question worth considering. Once we recognise that the barrel exists, what responsibility do we bear for its continued presence?
Those who created a particular arrangement may no longer be present, and those who maintain it may not fully recognise its consequences. Individuals operating within the system may possess different degrees of authority to influence its functioning, while others may have little opportunity to alter the conditions they experience.
Responsibility must therefore be considered in relation to knowledge, authority, capacity, and the possibilities available for action. It would be unreasonable to assign equal responsibility to everyone affected by a system, particularly when their ability to influence its arrangements differs considerably. Yet recognising these differences does not eliminate the importance of examining what each participant may contribute toward more constructive conditions.
For some, that contribution may involve developing a clearer understanding of the circumstances influencing their own behaviour. For others, it may involve improving relationships, reconsidering institutional practices so as to radically reshape them, or exercising leadership in ways that bring responsibilities, resources, and decision-making authority into greater alignment.
The larger objective is not simply to identify who should be blamed for the existence of the barrel. It is to understand how the barrel shapes the possibilities available within it and whether those possibilities can be expanded through more conscious action.
This brings me back to a distinction that has become increasingly central to my work. Human beings are not merely recipients of the social world they inherit. Through consciousness, interpretation, and collective activity, we participate in shaping the arrangements through which future experiences become possible. Because our constructs influence our outcomes, but those outcomes may also provide information through which our constructs can be reconsidered and refined. And when we recognise that fundamental relationship, the apparent inevitability of established arrangements begins to weaken. We may discover that circumstances we once regarded as permanent are instead expressions of decisions, assumptions, and practices that remain open to examination.
And perhaps this is where the crabs in a barrel metaphor offers its most important lesson.
If we focus exclusively upon the crabs, we may spend considerable time condemning their behaviour while leaving the conditions that contribute to it substantially unchanged. If we focus exclusively upon the barrel, we may overlook the responsibilities and capacities of the individuals whose actions continue to influence the situation.
As I see it, a more comprehensive understanding requires us to consider both, recognising that human behaviour emerges through the continuing relationship between individuals and the environments within which they live.
The question, then, is not merely why the crabs appear to pull one another down. It is why we have become so accustomed to interpreting their behaviour without first examining the circumstances in which they have been placed. And once we have examined those circumstances, perhaps the most consequential question is no longer who put the crabs in the barrel, but whether we possess the awareness, imagination, and willingness to create conditions in which the barrel is no longer necessary. If you have made it this far, I suspect you know my answer.
Suggested Practice | Examining the Barrel
Consider a situation in your personal, professional, or community life in which you have observed recurring competition, conflict, mistrust, or behaviour that appears to undermine cooperation. This may involve a workplace, educational institution, community organisation, family relationship, or another setting in which individuals are expected to pursue objectives that are at least partially shared.
Begin by reflecting upon how you have interpreted the behaviour of those involved. Have you attributed their conduct primarily to personality, character, motivation, or presumed deficiencies in their willingness to cooperate? If so, consider what additional understanding might emerge were you to examine the circumstances within which their behaviour occurs. Pay particular attention to how resources, expectations, responsibilities, authority, and opportunities are distributed, and whether the arrangements governing the situation encourage cooperation or inadvertently reward competition.
As you explore these questions, resist the temptation to replace one simplistic explanation with another. Recognising the influence of structural conditions does not eliminate individual responsibility, just as acknowledging personal agency does not render the surrounding environment irrelevant. Instead, seek to understand how the two interact and how their relationship may contribute to the outcomes you observe.
Next, consider whether there is an assumption, practice, expectation, or arrangement that could be reconsidered to improve the conditions under which those involved interact. The change need not be dramatic. It might begin with a more thoughtful conversation, a reconsideration of how responsibilities are assigned, greater transparency concerning shared resources, or a deliberate effort to align individual incentives with collective objectives.
Finally, turn the enquiry toward yourself. Are there circumstances in which you have responded to others primarily through assumptions about their character without adequately considering the conditions shaping their experience? Conversely, are there situations in which you have attributed your own difficulties entirely to external circumstances without examining the choices available to you?
The intention is to cultivate a more comprehensive understanding of human behaviour, one that recognises both the influence of our constructed environments and our capacity for intentional refinement. Through assessment, reflection, and conscious action, we may begin to develop conditions in which individual advancement and collective flourishing become increasingly compatible.
After all, recognising the barrel is only the beginning. What we choose to do with that recognition is where meaningful change becomes possible. And as I learned from my parents through considerable trial and error as a kid—Well begun is half done.
—
About the Author
Dr. Baruti KMT-Sisouvong is a consciousness scholar, researcher of human development, and Certified Teacher of Transcendental Meditation® based in Cambridge, Massachusetts. His work explores the relationships among Pure Consciousness, neuroscience, human development, and social systems, with particular attention to how expanded awareness can inform individual and collective transformation.
He is Founder and Chief Meditation Officer of Transcendental Brain, President of Serat Group Inc., and Founder of Radical Scholar Inc.. Alongside his wife, Mina, he co-directs the Transcendental Meditation programme for Cambridge and Greater Boston. He also hosts the On Transcendence Podcast and founded International Meditation Hour.
Learn more at barutikmtsisouvong.com.



